European leaders have pushed back against proposals for a sweeping new security arrangement between the United States and Russia, insisting that Europe and Ukraine must be involved in decisions affecting their future.

The dispute comes as Washington seeks progress towards ending Russia’s war in Ukraine. President Donald Trump has raised the possibility of what he called a “big, beautiful” agreement with Russia that could extend to European security as a whole. However, there is no completed agreement for the EU to approve or reject, and the US says European consent would be required.
What European leaders have said
EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas rejected the suggestion that Moscow should determine the continent’s security arrangements. Speaking on 6 November, she said: “Putin does not have a veto over European security.” She argued that existing agreements have been undermined by Russia breaching them, rather than by an absence of a security framework.
At the European Political Community summit in Dublin on Thursday 12 November, French President Emmanuel Macron said Europeans would define and decide their own security. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz called for European and Ukrainian representatives to be at the negotiating table alongside the US and Russia.
Kallas has also argued for a particular sequence: first a ceasefire, then a peace settlement, with discussions about Europe’s wider security framework following that. The emphasis contrasts with Washington’s efforts to explore the broader security questions alongside negotiations to end the war.
What Washington and Moscow are discussing
On 11 November, Axios reported, citing people familiar with the discussions, that the US had asked Russia to set out proposals for a future security agreement with Europe, including steps Moscow would be prepared to take to lower tensions. Such proposals should not be mistaken for terms already accepted by Washington or European capitals.
Russia has long sought limits on NATO enlargement and military deployments in eastern Europe. Those demands are especially sensitive because NATO members make their own decisions about collective defence and countries retain sovereignty over their security choices.
US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner met Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow on 12 November, following negotiations involving Russian and Ukrainian delegations in Abu Dhabi. Witkoff said European representatives would join the next round of talks. However, Kremlin adviser Yuri Ushakov did not give the same clear confirmation and criticised European military support for Ukraine.
What the Ukraine talks have achieved so far
The latest Abu Dhabi meetings produced progress towards a prisoner exchange, but no confirmed comprehensive peace agreement. European representatives held discussions with the US and Ukrainian sides, although they did not sit in the same negotiations with Russia.
In a joint statement on 10 November, the EU, France, Germany, Italy, the UK, Ukraine, the US and NATO stressed that future arrangements must respect sovereignty, territorial integrity and independent decision-making. They also said NATO would remain central to collective defence.
In Dublin, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy described US discussions with Russia about a new European security order as “a bit strange”. He said European governments were increasingly involved but should become regular participants, rather than merely being briefed after decisions were discussed elsewhere.
Why this matters beyond Ukraine
The issue is not only the terms of a possible ceasefire. A security framework could affect NATO deployments, future membership questions, Ukraine’s security guarantees and relations between Russia and neighbouring states for years to come.
The US position is not simply that Washington and Moscow should make the decisions alone. According to Axios, a source familiar with White House thinking said the US would not agree to a security deal without Europe and Ukraine and would not hand Russia a veto over European security. European leaders nevertheless want an effective place in the negotiations themselves.
What remains unresolved
- Whether Russia will agree to negotiate directly with European representatives, rather than holding separate talks with Washington.
- Who will represent European governments and institutions if a wider negotiating format is agreed.
- What Russia’s written security proposals will demand and what concessions Moscow may offer in return.
- Whether a ceasefire and enforceable guarantees for Ukraine can be agreed before wider security negotiations advance.
There is no signed Europe-Russia security deal and no confirmed agreement to alter NATO’s defence arrangements. The distinction matters: European leaders are resisting an approach and potential demands, not voting down a finished treaty.
Watch the video
What happens next
Further diplomatic contacts after Thursday’s meetings could clarify whether European representatives will join Russia at the table and whether the Kremlin will put forward a concrete proposal. Fish 4 News will report substantive developments separately rather than treating preliminary discussions as a concluded settlement.
Follow this story: Europe-Russia security talks.

