• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

F4N

  • Home
  • UK
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Travel
  • Sport
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Profiles
NewsAnalysis · 22 Nov

Who Will Replace Harry Kane? England’s Striker Options Explained

With Harry Kane recovering from ankle surgery, we assess Thomas Tuchel's striker alternatives, the false-nine option and England's Euro 2028 succession question.

Staff Reporter22 November 2026

Harry Kane’s ankle surgery has brought a question England could eventually face even when their captain is fit: who can take his place, and can Thomas Tuchel preserve the team’s attacking strengths without him? The answer may require more than choosing another centre-forward.

Fish 4 News editorial composite showing an illustrated Harry Kane in an England shirt, an empty number nine shirt and the headline Who Replaces Kane?
Images © Fish 4 News

Bayern Munich confirmed surgery on 21 November following a ligament tear in Kane’s left ankle. No definite return date was provided in the surgical announcement. With England next due to face Norway in March, the immediate selection issue and the longer-term question of succession have suddenly converged. Our separate injury report explains what is known about his operation and recovery.

Why replacing Harry Kane is more than a goalscoring problem

The Football Association credits Kane with 127 caps and 93 goals, both records for England’s senior men’s team. The 33-year-old is also the captain and England’s clearest reference point at the front of the attack.

In the six autumn matches of the 2026/27 UEFA Nations League, Kane scored eight times, in every game England played. England scored 19 goals in total, including an opposition own goal. Kane’s eight therefore accounted for roughly 42 per cent of the team’s goals, according to UEFA’s league-phase figures. It is significant evidence of his scoring importance, though not proof the team is incapable of winning without him.

His wider role explains why the replacement debate is harder than those figures suggest. Kane moves away from the penalty area to receive under pressure, connects midfielders with runners beyond him and can turn a long pass into possession higher up the pitch. That gives attacking players space to run into when defenders follow him. At the same time, his movement into the box and finishing remain the focal point of England’s attacks.

There is a useful counterweight to the dependence argument. Jude Bellingham finished the Nations League league phase with six assists, the most in the competition, while Anthony Gordon scored three England goals. England have creators and scorers beyond Kane. The question is whether their strengths translate as effectively when he is not linking the parts together. The UEFA statistical tables also credit Kane with an assist during the campaign.

England’s final group games offered both sides of the argument. Kane’s penalty was decisive in the 2-1 home victory over Croatia, and he scored again in the 3-2 win away to Spain that secured first place in their group. Against Spain, his capacity to hold up play also contributed to the sequence before England’s third goal. Those are not qualities a replacement gains simply by wearing the same shirt.

Bayern Munich face a parallel problem at club level, but Vincent Kompany can use a different pool of players and more time on the training ground. Our analysis of Bayern Munich’s attacking options without Harry Kane examines those tactical choices and the Bundesliga and Champions League implications.

What happened the last time England played without Kane?

On 31 March 2026, England lost 1-0 to Japan at Wembley. Tuchel tried Phil Foden in a false-nine arrangement before bringing on Dominic Solanke in the second half. The FA match report records 19 England shots, four on target and no goals. The result showed how an approach with extra technical players can still struggle to create clear chances.

But this was one friendly match, not a controlled experiment. England were also without other established players, the formation was unfamiliar and Japan defended effectively. Tuchel’s post-match comments specifically warned against treating the defeat as proof that the false-nine idea itself was wrong. He pointed to England’s lack of width and bravery in one-on-one situations.

That distinction is essential. A conventional striker does not automatically solve an ineffective attack. Equally, the absence of one can leave England short of an aerial target, penalty-box occupation and a player capable of holding the ball with his back to goal.

Who could replace Harry Kane for England?

There is no confirmed successor. Tuchel’s November squad included Kane and Dominic Calvert-Lewin among the forwards, with England’s other regular attackers tending to operate wider or behind the striker. Club circumstances and current form make the alternatives more varied than a simple Premier League shortlist.

Possible optionClub (Nov 2026)England caps/goalsMain tactical distinction
Dominic Calvert-LewinLeeds United15 / 4Traditional centre-forward and aerial target
Dominic SolankeTottenham5 / 0Pressing, movement and running channels
Ollie WatkinsAl-Hilal24 / 7Threat behind defenders
Ivan ToneyAl-Ahli10 / 1Hold-up play, physicality and finishing
Liam DelapNottingham Forest0 / 0Young penalty-box striker with power
Jude BellinghamReal Madrid62 / 14False-nine or attacking-midfield alternative
England appearances and goals from FA player profiles, checked 22 November 2026. These are tactical possibilities, not a squad announcement or a predicted selection.

Dominic Calvert-Lewin: the clearest conventional understudy

Calvert-Lewin has the strongest immediate claim on selection continuity. The Leeds striker was in both Tuchel’s September and November squads and was introduced late against Spain. His physical strength, heading and ability to compete for direct passes offer England a recognisable central point of attack. He also scored in Leeds’ 4-1 win at Chelsea on 21 November, part of an improved start to the league season.

The limitation is not his suitability as a target man but whether he can replicate Kane’s range of combination play or clinical finishing at international level. His injury history also argues against treating his availability in March as guaranteed. The short-term case for him rests on being familiar to Tuchel and requiring the fewest positional changes.

Dominic Solanke: more pressing and movement

Solanke remains at Tottenham and had scored twice in the Premier League this season by 21 November, including against Ipswich that day. His work without the ball and willingness to run channels could help England press more aggressively and threaten space behind defences. He has only five senior England appearances, however, and no international goals, and was not in Tuchel’s most recent squad.

His minutes against Japan are relevant experience, but not evidence that the system would succeed over a run of matches. A Solanke-led England might create opportunities through pressure and transition rather than Kane’s deeper passing. Recent club match logs support his regular involvement while also illustrating a relatively modest current scoring return.

Ollie Watkins: an experienced runner behind the defence

Watkins has 24 caps and seven England goals, and the memory of his late winner against the Netherlands at Euro 2024 demonstrates his ability to influence major matches. He now plays for Al-Hilal. Opta’s season statistics show five league goals and five assists in eight appearances in 2026/27.

Watkins would offer sharp diagonal runs, movement in behind and the ability to stretch opponents. England would need to deliver earlier passes into space rather than expecting him to reproduce Kane’s central playmaking. Tuchel did not select him in November, so naming him as the likely starter would go further than the evidence permits.

Ivan Toney: a strong scorer outside Tuchel’s recent plans

Toney continues to score regularly for Al-Ahli. Season data put him on 14 goals in 10 Saudi Pro League matches as of 21 November. He offers physical presence, hold-up play and a proven penalty technique. His senior England record stands at 10 caps and one goal.

Those club figures warrant attention, but a goal tally from a different league is not directly comparable with Premier League numbers. The more immediate selection question is why Tuchel has been looking elsewhere. Toney was absent from November’s squad, and there is no indication that he has been promised a recall.

Liam Delap: a possible successor, not yet an established answer

At 23, Delap is younger than the established alternatives and offers the most obvious long-term development case among the specialist centre-forwards discussed here. He is at Nottingham Forest, where his two goals against Manchester City on 7 November provided a striking demonstration of power and direct finishing.

That was an important performance, not proof that he is ready to lead England into a Nations League quarter-final. Delap has not made a senior England appearance and was not selected in November. His inclusion would be a development decision as much as a response to Kane’s injury. For Euro 2028, though, he is exactly the sort of player Tuchel and the England pathway need to assess.

Could Jude Bellingham play as a false nine?

This is not a theory invented because Kane is injured. In September, Tuchel spoke publicly about ending a match against Czechia with Bellingham in a central forward position. He said England would need a different answer rather than a replica of their captain. His comments were reported at the time, making Bellingham a documented option rather than merely a media suggestion.

A false nine drops away from centre-backs, linking midfield and attack while others advance into the spaces created. Our illustrated guide to what a false nine means in football explains why a defender following or holding position changes the attacking options. With Bellingham drifting centrally and Gordon, Morgan Rogers or Bukayo Saka attacking the spaces around him, England could become more fluid and harder to mark. The tactic could also give Rice and another midfielder an extra passing option during build-up play.

It would also come at a cost. The team might lose a consistent target for crosses and spend too much time with nobody occupying the penalty area. And Bellingham’s six Nations League assists are a reminder that moving him from his existing creative role could sacrifice a strength England already possess. There is no public indication that Tuchel has chosen the approach for Norway.

What about Anthony Gordon or another wide forward?

Gordon, now at Barcelona, is another player who could operate centrally in a more mobile attack. Opta records two La Liga goals and four assists for him this season, and he has 30 England caps and seven goals. His pace would make an England front line harder to catch when possession changes. He does not, however, offer Kane’s natural hold-up game or established penalty-area finishing.

Rogers, Saka and other attacking midfielders also broaden Tuchel’s options. That is part of England’s strength, but asking several of them to rotate through centre-forward would require rehearsed movement, not simply a changed name on a teamsheet.

Three realistic choices facing Thomas Tuchel

  • Keep a conventional No 9: start Calvert-Lewin, or recall Solanke, Watkins or Toney if form and fitness justify it. This maintains a penalty-box reference point but does not fully replace Kane’s playmaking.
  • Use Bellingham or Gordon centrally: prioritise interchange, pressing and runs from wide positions. England could become less predictable, but may lack an orthodox target against a compact defence.
  • Mix the two approaches: begin with a centre-forward and use a false nine later, or reverse the pattern depending on the opposition and game state. The key would be developing a rehearsed Plan B rather than improvising after an injury.

These are F4N tactical scenarios, not confirmed Tuchel selections. The head coach’s previous experiments and November squad inform the possibilities, but he has not publicly named Kane’s replacement.

Will Kane be back for England against Norway?

England’s next competitive fixtures are the Nations League quarter-final first leg away to Norway on 27 March 2027 and the return at Wembley on 30 March 2027, according to the FA’s fixture schedule. UEFA confirms that the winner can advance to the June finals.

Bayern said Kane’s operation had been successful and rehabilitation had begun. Reporting has suggested he could miss several months, but that is not a firm medical return timetable from the surgical announcement. March is more than four months after the injury. It is therefore too early to say that he will miss Norway, or that he is certain to play. Fitness and match sharpness may be separate questions if he returns close to those dates.

The Norway tie also has a tactical wrinkle. Erling Haaland scored six goals in Norway’s Nations League campaign. England may need to manage the contest without assuming that matching Norway goal for goal is their only route through it.

Does England have a longer-term striker problem ahead of Euro 2028?

Kane will be 34 when the next European Championship begins. Tuchel is contracted to lead England through the tournament, which will be staged in the UK and Ireland. The FA announced that extension in February 2026.

One view is that England’s football system has produced a generation of attacking midfielders and wide forwards without an obvious successor to its record scorer. Calvert-Lewin, Solanke, Watkins and Toney are all closer to Kane’s age than to Delap’s. The evidence of England’s current selections supports concern about the lack of a proven younger international No 9.

The counterargument is substantial. Elite teams increasingly share attacking responsibilities among several forwards, and a player of Kane’s unusual profile is unlikely to be reproduced on demand by any development system. England’s problem may be tactical adaptation rather than a simple shortage of strikers. Kane’s level also means that a healthy captain could remain the leading option for Euro 2028.

The most persuasive conclusion lies between alarm and complacency. England have credible replacements for individual tasks, including finishing, running behind, pressing and aerial play. What they have not yet demonstrated is a settled way to combine those tasks without Kane. Whether Tuchel solves that through a specialist striker or a reshaped attack may matter more than who starts one match in March.

Harry Kane replacement: key questions

Who is currently England’s most obvious replacement for Kane?

Dominic Calvert-Lewin is the clearest immediate conventional option because he was selected in Tuchel’s most recent squad. That does not mean he has been named as Kane’s replacement.

Could Jude Bellingham start up front for England?

Yes, as a tactical possibility. Tuchel discussed Bellingham as a No 9 in September, but has not announced that he will use him there against Norway.

Is Ollie Watkins still available for England?

Watkins is an England international and continues to play for Al-Hilal. He was not in the November squad, so a recall is a decision for Tuchel.

When are England’s next matches?

England travel to Norway on 27 March 2027 and host Norway at Wembley on 30 March in the UEFA Nations League quarter-finals.

Watch: Thomas Tuchel on England without Harry Kane

In this March 2026 press conference, Tuchel discusses the Japan defeat and why losing his captain changes England’s attacking options. The comments pre-date Kane’s November ankle injury.

Thomas Tuchel addresses England’s attacking difficulties without Kane after the defeat by Japan, March 2026 (HaytersTV).

Sources

  • Bayern Munich: successful surgery for Harry Kane, 21 November 2026
  • Football Association: Harry Kane player profile
  • UEFA: 2026/27 Nations League leading scorers
  • UEFA: Nations League player statistics and assists
  • Football Association: England’s November 2026 squad
  • Football Association: Tuchel’s reaction to England 0-1 Japan
  • Football Association: England’s March 2027 fixtures
  • Football Association: Tuchel’s Euro 2028 contract
  • Nottingham Forest: Delap double against Manchester City

More from Fish 4 News

Fish 4 News composite showing Harry Kane and Bayern Munich manager Vincent Kompany beside a tactical pitch graphic, with the headline Bayern Without Kane
NewsAnalysis · 22 Nov

Can Bayern Munich Win Without Harry Kane? Kompany’s Striker Options Explained

Harry Kane's injury leaves Vincent Kompany facing a tactical test. Bayern's striker options, attacking statistics and Bundesliga and Champions League implications analysed.

Editorial composite showing a British service member from behind, the Union flag, a military aircraft and a warship, with the words 'Recruitment Recovers' and 'Trained Strength Still Below Target'.
NewsAnalysis · 20 Nov

UK Armed Forces Recruitment Recovers but Trained Strength Remains Below Target

More personnel are joining than leaving the UK Armed Forces, but MOD figures show trained strength remains below 2023 levels and earlier targets.

Fish 4 News

Independent news, context and analysis designed to help readers make up their own minds. News informs and verifies; opinion is clearly labelled.

Explore

  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Profiles
  • Editorial Standards
  • Corrections

Information

  • About Fish 4 News
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms / Disclaimer
F4NFish 4 News

We don’t tell you what to think. We tell you what we know.

© 2026 Fish 4 News